Employee Retirement Allocations, Earnings Surprises, and Stock Return

Working Paper
2023 ACEM Doctoral Students Forum

Who knows firms’ earnings first, and how does that information enter prices? This paper shows that rank-and-file employees incorporate information about contemporaneous earnings into their retirement-saving decisions before markets do. Using U.S. defined-contribution plan data from 2003 to 2023, we find that changes in employee ownership during fiscal year t predict earnings surprises for that same year, which are revealed only when earnings are announced in early year t+1. Stock prices adjust to this information primarily around the announcement window, generating short-lived abnormal returns. The effects are stronger when information frictions are high, disappear once plan disclosures become public, and are absent in sponsor-directed plans. These patterns indicate that employee allocations aggregate dispersed internal signals that markets incorporate with delay. The results highlight a previously unexplored mechanism through which internal information diffuses into asset prices.

Access the paper via SSRN